Adventures in (Post) Gradland

Thoughts on life after the PhD

The Virtuality Invasion

I first wrote about the weird world of virtual existences back in 2003, when NHK ran a story about the increasing popularity of “virtual communities” among Japanese housewives, college students, and lonely singles.  That was before Second Life, before World of Warcraft, before even Facebook and Twitter became household words (sheesh, was it really only six years ago?).  Here’s what I had to say back then:

In a city like Tokyo, where the masses yearn to escape the daily coffee-commute-work-commute-sleep routine, online gaming has caught on in a big way. One of the more popular kinds of ‘virtual worlds’ involves the buying and selling of virtual real estate and merchandise. Buying a home is a dream that’s out of reach for most Tokyoites–the downpayment alone could be over a million dollars, and that’s for a house that would probably be classified as an apartment anywhere else–but in the virtual world anyone can become a homeowner. After you buy your virtual house (with virtual money obtained from selling virtual goods–anyone else getting dizzy?) you can make additions to it, decorate it, even plant a garden–all from the comfort of your own PC. One housewife interviewed by NHK news admitted to spending up to ELEVEN HOURS A DAY decorating and buying things for her virtual house.

Virtual real estate has become so popular, in fact, that art has started to imitate life–Tokyo is one of the first online communities to be suffering from a VIRTUAL REAL ESTATE SHORTAGE. How something that doesn’t exist in the first place can be hard to come by is beyond me (six years later I realize that it might be an issue of web space), but according to online gamers there just isn’t any more space for them to build their virtual mansions. Thus the birth of VIRTUAL REAL ESTATE BROKERS, people who charge REAL money for virtual land. Prices vary, but the aforementioned housewife says she paid close to 100,000 yen (about US$900) for her virtual land and the house that sits on it. Virtual real estate brokers are raking it in–one admitted to making several hundred thousand yen a month in sales.

As if paying real money for nonexistent land weren’t enough, last week a man was arrested in Tokyo for selling someone else’s virtual house. Seems he hacked into another player’s ID and pretended to be her for several days, finally convincing another player to purchase her virtual house for 50,000 yen (about US$400). When questioned the thief said he needed the money to pay off debts (maybe incurred from spending endless hours in Internet cafes). It may be the first time in Tokyo’s history that a person has been prosecuted for stealing a virtual house.

I used to lump Second Life / World of Warcraft enthusiasts into a category that included furries, Dungeons and Dragons players, and hard-core cosplay fans–harmless, but kind of icky.  Having learned a little more about online communities and online games, I realize that players and venues come in many different shapes and sizes and it’s not fair to stereotype them.  There is, I think, a crucial difference between 1) logging on to an online game / community a few times a week and 2) spending so much time in virtual worlds that you lose touch with reality and your health begins to suffer.  I’ve spent time in online communities and played online games, and it was fun, but I don’t understand the concept of a live lived online.  Sure, I’m online several hours a day, but my online activities are pretty mundane–doing school-related research, reading newspapers, exchanging emails, and, all right, watching pointless YouTube videos and looking at pictures of cats.  The idea of living in a virtual city, creating a virtual identity, having a virtual relationship, even friending people on Facebook that I’ve never met and am unlikely to meet in the future just isn’t for me. 

My way of thinking seems to be going the way of the dinosaur, though.  More and more people are choosing to live out otherwise unreachable dreams online.  The latest hotbed of virtual activity is China, where an online game called “Audition,” similar to American Idol but for dancers, is all the rage.  NPR reports that thousands of young people log on every day to make their virtual characters dance and flaunt themselves in fashionable clothes.  If they want the latest clothes and accessories, they have to buy them with real money.  And they get extra points when they hook up with a member of the opposite sex, or when someone tells them that they’re good looking. 

Pardon me, but how sad is this?  You’d think people would venture into an online world to escape the kinds of pressures and exclusion that they feel in the real world, but no–art really does imitate life.  The big difference, of course, is that in the online world everyone CAN be gorgeous and fashionable–they just have to pay for it.  The geek can be a jock, the chubby girl can be a supermodel.  Never mind that none of it’s real. 

Or maybe it is.  I’ve argued frequently that virtual relationships aren’t the same as those that take place face to face, and I’ll stand by that–but the line between reality and virtuality is starting to get a lot thinner.  If your online best friend is providing you with everything you want from a real best friend–praise, support, laughs, understanding, a listening ear–who’s to say that a friend you see face-to-face is really better? 

All I know is that the growing dependence on virtual worlds and virtual relationships scares me.  It’s part of an overall trend that I find alarming–the absorption of knowledge and meaning through sound bites and quick montages rather than thoughtful reasoning, the creation of ideals of beauty and coolness that can never be matched in the corporeal world, and the desire to retreat into fantasy rather than fight for change in reality. 

I’m not calling for a boycott of any kind.  I’m not even saying that venues like World of Warcraft and Second Life shouldn’t exist.  We all need our little escapes, even dorky ones.  I blog, after all–aren’t I attempting to create exactly the sort of virtual “community” that I’m criticizing?  Maybe.  But it’s different somehow–maybe because I feel that 80% of my daily existence still happens away from the computer.  What I fear is the glorification of the virtual at the expense of the corporeal.  When the wall is finally breached and we have, as Baudrillard famously described, copies without originals, I think I might start contemplating a move to Bhutan.


2 comments on “The Virtuality Invasion

  1. Jennifer
    April 10, 2009

    I’d hate to see Warcraft lumped together with Second Life, because one’s “virtual identity” on Warcraft is nothing like that on Second Life. It’s used for playing a game, not as a social stand-in. Sure, maybe I’m just saying this because I occasionally play, and don’t want to think of myself as icky, but I don’t see it as being that different from console RPGs. The Internet just makes it easy to play alongside someone across the country, if that’s what you want to do. I know there are tens of thousands of people out there who end up playing with (and getting to know) people they’ve never met before, but it’s only the minority who use those opportunities to hook up with like-minded geeks. Most of us just play alone, with a few close friends, or the occasional stranger.

  2. gradland
    April 10, 2009

    You’re absolutely right, and I should have emphasized the “used to” factor–since I’ve learned more about venues like Second Life and Warcraft I’ve realized there’s a lot more to both of them than meets the eye, and it’s not fair to immediately stereotype people who play either one. I’ve played around with Second Life and also tried out some online RPGs a while back and had fun doing it. I suppose my point is that they’re fine when they’re a pasttime or a game, but for me the ick factor sets in when people spend eight or nine hours a day in virtual worlds and start talking about those virtual worlds as if they’re real.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s


This entry was posted on April 8, 2009 by in Uncategorized and tagged , .
Anne McKnight

writing•translation•scholarship on Japan (and a few other things)

A Modern Girl / モダンガール

tales of travel, research, and life is the best place for your personal blog or business site.

%d bloggers like this: